What’s Next? – Part II

Congress principally acts by enacting legislation. To be sure, it has the power to conduct hearings to gather information which it uses in fashioning the legislation it sends to the president. Standing in the way of Congressional Democrats is that most of the problems they will be seeking to rectify have either been created or made worse by President Trump. Therefore, even though he has said that he intends to work with the newly elected Democratic controlled Congress, he has also said that he’s ready and willing to veto legislation they might pass. Notwithstanding this warning, Congressional Democrats will try to proceed with many of the legislative changes thatAmericans are now demanding. This will place Republican legislators in the uncomfortable position of either voting against Democratic bills with significant popular appeal or inviting the ire of a vindictive President Trump who may have the power to bring their political careers to an end.

While presidential vetoes may be overridden by votes of two-thirds of the House and Senate members, based on the results of the recent elections, that will require at least some Republican members of Congress to vote in favor of overriding Trump’s vetoes. As noted in Part I of this article, President Trump possesses an insurance policy against that happening in the form of a $164.3 million campaign war chest which he can use to threaten any Republican member of Congress who votes to override one of his vetoes. The result is likely to be that Trump will have a major voice in the terms of all legislation not subject to the Senate filibuster rule that gets enacted during the balance of his presidency.

The likely opposition of the Trump administration and Congressional Republicans to the Democrats’ legislative agenda explains why Congressional Democrats may be devoting most of their time holding hearings spotlighting the problems currently plaguing working class Americans. While these hearings may be more political theater than a foundation for Congressional action, they will be important to winning back the goodwill of working class Americans who have lost confidence in the Democratic Party as a result of the constant onslaught of criticism heaped upon them by Trump and the right-wing media. 

In addition to compelling the publication of the Epstein Files and exposing the malefactors whose exploits are recorded therein, Congressional hearings are likely to target :

(a) the decisions made relating to the war in Iran, 

(b) the Trump family’s business dealings, 

(c) Trump’s abuses of his pardon powers, 

(d) the DOJ’s misuse of the nation’s criminal justice system, 

(e) the abusive tactics of the Department of Homeland Security against illegal aliens,

(f) the DOJ’s failure to enforce the nation’s antitrust laws, 

(g) the dangers and costs of embracing artificial intelligence, 

(h) securities trading on inside information by government officials, and

(i) the Trump administration’s efforts to undermine political elections.

​ The immediate focus of the new Democratic-controlled Congress will be on the affordability crisis now affecting 60+ percent of Americans. This will mean rolling back many of the provisions of Trump’s “One Big Beautiful Bill.” These efforts will likely include eliminating (a) tax cuts for the wealthy, (b) cuts to the IRS’s enforcement budget, (c) cuts to the Medicare,Medicaid and Affordable Care programs, (d) cuts to federal nutrition programs, and (e) cuts to foreign aid programs designed to prevent the importation of infectious diseases. It will also include rolling back Trump’s unilateral and unlawful impositions of tariffs which raise the costs of hundreds of items regularly consumed by Americans. 

​ The costs which disturb Americans the most are the high prices of gasoline and diesel fuels which can be directly traced to the war in Iran. That war is also responsible for higher pricesfor fertilizer which have been having a devastating effect on our nation’s farmers. Although President Trump has threatened additional military action to bring the Iran war to an end, he also keeps saying that the Iranians are desperate to end the war. His statements, however, have been contradicted by Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s reports that there remain wide differences in the positions of the U.S. and Iranian negotiators. 

Notwithstanding Trump’s happy talk about the prospects for a negotiated peace, he’s doing little, if anything, to end the war. This is likely because there are few concessions that the Iranians might be willing to make that will enable President Trump to claim a victory; and ending the war without having achieved some positive goals is something he’s clearly loathe to do. In addition, he’s not personally being hurt by the continuation of the war which also has proven to be a godsend for our nation’s fossil-fuel industries and for his buddy Vladimir Putin. Indeed, Putin has taken advantage of the continuinghostilities in Iran to step up Russia’s bombing of Ukraine most likely in an effort to force the Ukrainian government capitulate on his terms before our new Congress is seated. 

​ The sad fact is that there is little that a Democratic controlled Congress can do to force the President to end this misbegotten conflict. That’s because any legislation passed by the Congress cutting off defense spending on the war will not be veto-proof; and our child-like president tends to react badly to being told what to do. A more promising approach would be for both houses of Congress to pass near unanimous non-binding resolutions expressing the sense of the Congress to bring the war to an end. In this way, President Trump, seeing that he can blame the Congress for a disappointing conclusion of the war, might be willing to negotiate its end. Even if President Trump seeks to end the war, there could still be lingering problems because the Israelis and the Iranians will remain at war, raising the possibility that the Iranians may be unwilling to reach any settlement that does not bind Israel. That means that a renewed effort to negotiate an end to the war may either be a non-starter and/or an extraordinarily long affair.​

​ Congressional Democrats will also be seeking to curb political corruption which has reached new heights under the Trump administration. This will include prohibiting members of the Congress and the Executive Branch from insider securities trading violations. This will require high ranking government officials to place their business interests in trusts managed by independent trustees and prohibit efforts to utilize their positions for personal gain. These prohibitions are also likely to be extended to non-government employees (like Jared Kushner) who perform services for the government. While Congressional Democrats will be under a lot of public pressure to address this issue, they are also unlikely to get any meaningful cooperation from the Trump administration.

​ Similarly, the new Congress will be under public pressure to take some meaningful steps to put the nation’s fiscal operations on a more sustainable course. This will include raising corporate taxes and income taxes on wealthy individuals and closing a multitude of tax loopholes which allow them to pay individual federal income taxes at a lower rate than working class Americans. This will not be easy to accomplish as most House and Senate members rely heavily on the campaign contributions provided by the corporations and individuals who would be affected by these changes. In addition, without rolling back the cuts to the IRS’s budget, many wealthy individuals will be able to understate their federal income tax liabilities.

Another area of fiscal reform will be the nation’s defense budget which currently exceeds the combined defense budgets of the six other nations with the largest defense budgets. Underlying our nation’s wasteful defense spending is the manner in which our defense contracts are negotiated. Almost half of them are awarded on a no-bid basis and a reported 50% are awarded on a cost-plus basis. Not coincidentally, our nation’s largest defense contractors are also among the nation’s largest political campaign contributors. Not only is the amount of our defense spending far more than that of other nations, the current wars in Ukraine and Iran are demonstrating that simple and inexpensive weaponry is significantly more cost-effective thanthe billion dollar weapon systems that currently dominate our defense spending. In addition, the Department of Defense hasn’t had a clean audit report in several years; and it has been estimated that 65% of the DOD’s assets can’t even be located. Simply stated, our nation’s defense establishment is long overdue for a complete overhaul in addition to a substantial reduction in its annual budgets.

Another area of government expenditures crying out for better fiscal management is the nation’s large array of welfare programs which consume almost two-thirds of all federal expenditures. Here, the problem isn’t fraud, waste and abuse as the Republicans politicians contend. It’s that many of those programs were conceived many years ago in different social and demographic environments and are ill-suited in today’s environment. 

For example, social security was enacted in 1935 when the life expectancy of Americans was 70 years. At that time, the average social security recipient would receive benefits for only five years. Today, the average life expectancy of Americans is 79 which means that social security benefits are provided almost three times as long as they were when the program was initiated. Moreover, in 1935 there were roughly 160 workers contributing into the program for every retiree receiving benefits. Today, there are only 2.7 workers contributing to the program for every retiree receiving benefits. The result is that the social security program must be substantially reformed if it is to continue to operate on a sustainable basis.

This is also true of many of the other social welfare programs which already receive a high level of scrutiny to prevent fraud, waste and abuse. They too are in serious need of re-examination. The problem is that there are over 100 million Americans receiving benefits under these programs which makes it politically difficult to enact changes in them. As a result, administration after administration talks about reforming them but does little or nothing to make them more economically viable. At worst, Congress simply tries to cut the budgets of these programs on the assumption that the program administrators will find ways to operate them on a more sustainable basis. This is a flawed approach since program administrators generally have little authority to make structural changes in the programs they administer. 

The reality is that any significant changes in these programs will only be achieved through bi-partisan efforts. This might be possible if the incoming Speaker of the House were to appoint small committees consisting of an equal number of members from both parties to explore structural changes for each class of social welfare programs. Those committees should have co-chairs from both political parties and be empowered to call upon the expertise of outside professionals. While it’s unlikely that legislation will be adopted during the remainder of President Trump’s term in office, this approach could help restore some public confidence in what has been a do-nothing Congress and set the stage for real reform following the 2028 election. 

A major factor in the affordability and deficit spending problems facing the nation is our out-of-control healthcare system. Although the U.S. has the world’s most advanced healthcare system, per capita healthcare costs in the U.S. are literally twice as high as those in all other developed nations. Perhaps even more embarrassing is that approximately 90 million Americans (or 27%) are underinsured and roughly 65million (or 20%) are unable to even afford any healthcare expenditures. This has led to 60,000 unnecessary deaths each year from a want of medical care. In addition, medical debts annually lead to the bankruptcy of an estimated 500,000 Americans.

It’s not just that healthcare has become too costly for a significant portion of Americans, it’s rapidly becoming too costly for the U.S. government to underwrite. That’s because our federal government already spends an estimated 27% of its total annual expenditures on its various healthcare programs. By contrast, other developed nations, including those that providehealthcare for all of their citizens, only devote an average of 15% of their total government expenditures to healthcare. In short, the U.S. has an economically unsustainable level of expenditures which is almost sure to increase over the next few years, crowding out even more public needs. More detailed discussions of these problems can be found by clicking here.

The most effective way to address high healthcare costs is to establish a national healthcare insurance program that will finance the healthcare needs of the vast majority of Americans. That’s because our private health insurance industry is a major contributor to our nation’s high healthcare costs.  It’s not just that private healthcare insurers are ineffective in limitingincreases in healthcare costs, they actually add to those costs in three important ways. 

First, they have substantial administrative costs collecting money from their insureds and controlling the scope of healthcare costs which they underwrite. Those costs represent 12% to 20% of the monies they pay out on behalf of their insureds. Secondly, private healthcare insurers provide important services for their insureds for which they charge a roughly 1.5% profit on top of their operating costs. Lastly, in order to guard against runaway healthcare costs, all of the nation’s 1000+ private healthcare insurers have a myriad of rules as to what healthcare costs they will and will not pay. While this helps them protect their own profitability, it poses an administrative nightmare for healthcare providers who have to comply with the varying rules of the multitude of insurers which pay their invoices. That administrative burden represents roughly 10% of the operating costs of healthcare provider. The bottom line is that roughly 25% of total healthcare costs could be eliminated simply by eliminating private healthcare insurers and moving to a single-payer government insurance system, which virtually all other developed nations employ. 

Underlying a portion of our nation’s run-away healthcare cost is the problem of high prescription drug costs. This is a much smaller, but nevertheless significant (roughly 11%), part of total healthcare costs. Prescription drugs in the U.S. cost roughly 2.5 times what the same drugs cost in other developed countries. The major U.S. pharmaceutical companies seek to justify their higher domestic prices claiming that they effectively subsidize drug costs in other nations by bearing a large portion of the costs of formulating safe and effective drugs. It’s an intriguing, but nevertheless fallacious, argument because ournation’s largest prescription drug manufacturers enjoy after-tax profit margins that are more than twice the average profit margins of the nation’s other major manufacturing companies.

It’s not just that pharmaceutical manufacturers are engaged in an indisputably high-risk industry and are therefore entitled to high profit margins. The principal problem is that there are unholy alliances among our large prescription drug companies, our drug wholesalers and retailers, the prescription benefitmanagers and the prescription drug insurers. While these alliances should be the subject of Congressional and judicial oversight, the participants in these alliances have significant political clout which has enabled their collusive arrangements to continue undisturbed. Like most of the economic problems vexing our federal government, those continuing to plague the prescription drug industry can be traced to the Supreme Court’s decision in Citizens United v. FEC which opened the floodgates to unlimited political contributions. Thus, until that decision is reversed and/or new campaign financing restrictions are enacted, it is highly unlikely that most of these problems can be successfully addressed.

A final problem crying out for Congressional attention is the fate of the nation’s 11+ million illegal aliens. This is a very emotional problem with very real economic consequences. Most illegal aliens came to this country as migrant workers helping American farmers to plant and harvest their crops and returning to their homes countries when their seasonal work was completed. When the U.S. began to restrict the entry of immigrants, those individuals and their families chose to remain in the U.S. as illegal aliens rather than risk not being readmitted the following year. Although the Senate in 2013 fashioned comprehensive immigration reform legislation designed to provide illegal aliens with a path to become citizens, Donald Trump called upon House Republican members not to support the legislation as he wished to exploit the nation’s immigration issues for political purposes. To that end, he branded illegal immigrants as “murders, rapists and drug dealers” and vowed to deport “the worst of the worst.” 

Although he was able to restrict immigration during his first term as our president, he embarked on a full-scale racial cleansing agenda at the beginning of his current term in office, seeking to round up and deport 3,000 illegal aliens a day. At first, he sent airplane-loads of detainees to notoriously brutal prison camps in foreign countries in an effort to both discourage future immigrants and encourage those already in our country to self-deport. This tactic was quickly halted when the courts ruled that detainees were entitled to due process before being deported. This led the Trump administration to erect detention camps around the country to house immigrant detainees until they had an opportunity to contest their arrests and deportations. These domestic detention facilities were also made as brutal as possible and they have been the sites of numerous deaths from beatings, malnutrition and a want of medical care.

This does not fully describe the problems with Trump’s treatment of illegal aliens because numerous U.S. citizens, as well as legal immigrants, have been swept up by immigration enforcement (ICE) agents. Indeed, roughly 70% of the immigrants who have been detained have no criminal records. Moreover, the tactics utilized by ICE agents are in many respects worse than those used by the Gestapo in Nazi Germany. A significant percentage of ICE agents have been given little training and seem to have been instructed to be as brutal as possible. They wear face masks, display no personal identity, ride in unmarked vehicles and utilize undue force in making arrest. They have on occasion fired their weapons at individuals whom they perceive as interfering with their actions. Even when these agents have been identified as having acted improperly, they are not prosecuted. 

It’s not at all clear what the Congress can do, if anything, to stop this lawless activity as any legislation which Congress may pass is likely to be vetoed by President Trump who stands fully behind what immigration officials have been doing. It should also be noted that the architect of these activities is Stephen Miller whom Trump just promoted to be his Chief-of-Staff and who has vowed to continue these activities.

To be sure, it will be difficult for a Democratic controlled Congress to pass significant tax legislation, reign in defense spending and reform the nation’s healthcare and immigration systems as all of those reforms must not only get past the Senate filibuster rule, but also must overcome a veto by President Trump. Thus, the most that may be accomplished in these areas is to shine a spotlight on the issues and hope that will enable them to obtain control of the White House and both houses of Congress following the 2028 elections which, in turn, may enable them actually achieve significant remedial reforms.

Next
Next

What's Next? – Part I